The Bengals Went .500 for Six Years and Beat the Spread More Than Almost Anyone

Ten weeks into 2026, the Cincinnati Bengals are 7-2 straight up and lead the AFC North by a game. They score 30.9 points a game, third in the league. On Monday night they visit Washington as 6-point favorites.

The more unusual story is the six seasons before this one. From 2020 to 2025 the Bengals won exactly half of their regular-season games, and only one team in the league beat the point spread more often.

How they got to 7-2

Week Game Score Spread faced Against the spread Total
1 vs Buccaneers W 33-27 -3.5 Beat it by 2.5 Over 50.5
2 at Texans W 20-6 +3 Beat it by 17 Under 45.5
3 at Steelers L 27-30 -3.5 Missed by 6.5 Over 42.5
4 vs Jaguars L 17-22 -2.5 Missed by 7.5 Under 51.5
5 at Dolphins W 31-24 -7 Push Over 44.5
6 bye
7 at Ravens W 35-13 -3 Beat it by 19 Over 46.5
8 vs Titans W 43-36 (OT) -13.5 Missed by 6.5 Over 46.5
9 vs Falcons (Madrid) W 34-17 -3 Beat it by 14 Under 52.5
10 vs Steelers W 38-18 -4.5 Beat it by 15.5 Over 49.5

7-2 straight up, 5-3-1 against the spread, 6-3 on the total.

The Week 9 game was played at the Santiago Bernabéu in Madrid and is listed in our data as an Atlanta home game, which is how the league scheduled it.

The offense is among the best in the league. By EPA per play the Bengals rank third passing, and their average margin of +9.4 points a game is tied for third. The running game is less productive: 22nd by rushing EPA.

The run defense is the weakness. They allow 21.4 points a game, 10th, and rank 12th against the pass by EPA, but 31st against the run. The Week 8 game shows the mix: 13.5-point favorites against the Titans, now 1-8, they won 43-36 in overtime and missed the spread.

Both of the Bengals' losses came early, at Pittsburgh and at home to Jacksonville. They have won five straight since, and beaten the spread in three of them by a combined 48.5 points. The Jaguars, who won 22-17 in Cincinnati in Week 4, are 7-2 as well; our Jaguars profile covers them.

A .500 team the market kept underrating

Regular season, 2020-2025 Record League rank
Straight up 50-49-1 (50.5%) 16th
Against the spread 57-41-2 (58.0%) 2nd

Only Detroit (61.4%) beat the spread more often over those six seasons. Compare the two teams at the top of the straight-up table: Buffalo won 73% of its games and ranked fourth against the spread, and Kansas City won 71% and ranked 28th. Winning and beating the spread are different things, and the Bengals are the clearest example in the league of the gap between them. Our Bills profile covers the other end.

They did it in both roles: 60.4% as favorites and 55.3% as underdogs in those seasons.

With Joe Burrow, and without him

A .500 record over six seasons hides two different teams. Joe Burrow missed significant time in 2020, 2023 and 2025, and the market priced the Bengals very differently depending on who played quarterback.

Regular season, 2020-2025 Games Straight up Against the spread Average spread
Burrow led the team in pass attempts 76 42-33-1 (55.9%) 46-29-1 (61.2%) Favored by 1.3
Another quarterback did 24 8-16 (33.3%) 11-12-1 (47.9%) Underdog by 4.5

"Led the team in pass attempts" is how we identify the starter from game data. It includes the games where Burrow was injured during the game, if he had already thrown the most passes.

Without Burrow, the market's price was about right. The Bengals were underdogs by four and a half points a game and finished just under half against the spread.

With him, the market priced the Bengals as a slightly-better-than-average team. They were, winning 55.9% of their games, but they beat the spread in 61.2%. It held whether they were favored (28-18-1) or not (18-11). The margins were small, about one point beyond the spread on average, so this was a price that was a little short, game after game, not a team that routinely blew past it.

Forty-six of 75 decided games would turn up by chance about one time in twenty. We chose this split because the quarterback is the obvious variable, not because we searched many splits for it, but it is still 76 games. It describes the Burrow years. It is not a reason to expect any particular result.

The road team

One split runs through all 24 seasons, not just the Burrow years. The Bengals have done better against the spread away from Cincinnati.

Regular season, against the spread At home On the road
2002-2013 42-51-3 (45.3%) 48-43-5 (52.6%)
2014-2025 48-47-3 (50.5%) 59-37-2 (61.2%)
2002-2025 90-98-6 (47.9%) 107-80-7 (57.0%)
2020-2025, Burrow starts 19-16-1 (54.2%) 27-13 (67.5%)

The gap held in both halves of the data, which is the test we used for the Giants' home-road split. It is also the kind of split we found by looking, among many we could have checked, and a record like 107-80 would turn up by chance about one time in twenty. On the road the Bengals were usually underdogs, by about two and a half points on average. In 2026 they are 4-1 straight up and 3-1-1 against the spread away from Cincinnati, counting Madrid.

January

Playoffs, since 2002 Straight up Against the spread
Before the 2021 season 0-7 2-5
2021-2022 seasons 5-2 5-2

The Bengals lost their first seven playoff games of the period, five of them by double digits. Then the 2021 team won three in a row, including the AFC Championship 27-24 in overtime at Kansas City as a 7-point underdog, and lost the Super Bowl 23-20 to the Rams. The 2022 team won two more and lost the AFC Championship 23-20 at Kansas City again.

They have not played a playoff game since. Fourteen games is not a sample, and every one of the seven wins came with Burrow at quarterback.

Twenty-four seasons against the spread

2002-2025 Record Pct
Against the spread, regular season 197-178-13 52.4%
Against the spread, playoffs 7-7 50.0%
Straight up, regular season 185-199-4 48.2%
Straight up, playoffs 5-9 35.7%

The 2022 Bills-Bengals game, suspended in the first quarter and never completed, is not counted.

Over the full 24 seasons the Bengals rank seventh of 32 against the spread. The two halves read differently: 49.0% from 2002 to 2013, and 55.9% from 2014 to 2025, second in the league over those twelve seasons behind Minnesota.

Regular season, 2002-2025 Against the spread Pct
Favored 88-83-8 51.4%
Underdog 105-92-5 53.2%
Favored, 2020-2025 31-20-2 60.4%
Underdog, 2020-2025 26-21 55.3%

Pushes count as half in every percentage, the same rule the site uses.

Monday night in Washington

The Bengals visit Northwest Stadium on Monday, November 23, favored by 6 with a total of 54.5. That is the highest total of any Bengals game this season.

Washington is 3-5-1, scores 21.8 points a game and allows 24.8. By EPA it ranks 32nd against the run, the only team in the league rated below Cincinnati there. The Bengals' own running game ranks 22nd. The line can move before kickoff.

What the data supports

  • The Bengals are 7-2, lead the AFC North and are third in scoring, with the league's 31st-ranked run defense by EPA.
  • From 2020 to 2025 they went 50-49-1 and ranked second against the spread. Winning and beating the spread are different records.
  • With Burrow, 46-29-1 against the spread; without him, 11-12-1. The market priced the backups about right and Burrow's teams a little short, by about a point a game. A strong lean, not proof.
  • The road split has held for 24 seasons: 57.0% away, 47.9% at home, in both halves of the data. Found by looking, and it describes the past.
  • The playoff record is 5-9, and all five wins came in the 2021 and 2022 seasons. Too few games to be a pattern.

See it yourself